By Ben Neary
NMWF Conservation Director
Private landowners have no right to block a road that the public has used for decades to access a trailhead into the Aldo Leopold Wilderness, a state district judge has ruled in response to a lawsuit filed by the New Mexico Wildlife Federation and a group of Sierra County residents.
District Judge Shannon Murdock-Poff on Nov. 20 issued an order directing landowners Mark and Ruth Bennett not to obstruct public use of GIla National Forest Road 40E.
“Defendant (the Bennetts) shall not obstruct any access to the road for the public or shall be subject to public nuisance claims,” the judge wrote.
Noting there are quail in the area, the judge wrote, “Hunters are unable to access the area due to the road being blocked.”
Although the public has used the road for decades, the Bennets put a locked gate and no-trespassing signs on the road after they acquired in 2022 a small parcel of land that the road crosses.
The NMWF and the Percha Creek Association filed a lawsuit last year asserting that the public had established an easement over the roadway through decades of public use.
It fell to the NMWF and the association to act after the U.S. Forest Service refused to act to reopen the road after the Bennetts closed it.
“This is a tremendous victory for all New Mexicans,” said Jesse Deubel, executive director of the New Mexico Wildlife Federation.
“Across the West, our public lands are under assault from landowners who seek to lock the public out,” Deubel said. “In this case, the New Mexico Wildlife Federation had to join with local residents to stand up for the public’s rights when the Forest Service itself refused to act. The public deserves better.”
Deubel credited lawyers Gene Gallegos of Santa Fe and David Baake of Las Cruces for their work to reopen the road. “Gene and David did great work, and anyone in New Mexico who’s thinking of trying to lock the public out of public lands should pay close attention to this case,” he said.
Gallegos said he welcomes the judge’s ruling. “I commend the court on doing the hard work of reviewing the entire record in order to arrive at a reversal of the prior ruling and to come to a just result,” he said.
The road runs from the town of Kingston to the entry of the Aldo Leopold Wilderness portion of the Gila National Forest. The road leads up the canyon that holds Percha Creek to a trailhead on the Ladrone Gulch Trail, which heads into the Black Range and the Aldo Leopold Wilderness.
Murdock-Poff held a hearing last December at which many area residents testified they had used the road to reach the wilderness for decades.
After last year’s hearing, Murdock-Poff entered an order denying the public easement claim. The NMWF and the Percha Creek Association appealed that decision, but the NM Court of Appeals ruled that the judge hadn’t yet entered a final order in the case so the appeal was premature.
Murdock-Poff’s new order states that her previous ruling was in error. She ruled that a 20-foot wide public easement exists that follows the same route that the road has followed since 1950 through the Bennett’s property to the trailhead.
The road has been delineated on U.S. Forest Service maps as Forest Road 40E for decades. The judge’s order notes that the Forest Service had refused to enter as a party to the lawsuit.